Monday, February 17, 2014

A Candidate Resolution to the Locke-Rousseau Dichotomy

A resolution to the Lockean-Rousseauian dichotomy may be that the human experience takes place in both of these realities concurrently, with a slight preference for the Rousseauian reality. The human condition has one foot in both at all times. These realities are disjoint. Our traditional fives senses perceive the Lockean world, while our softer senses perceive the Rousseauian world.

This may sound a little contradictory, but if you read carefully, I'm just saying they're disjoint while still both existing quite fine. We don't have to push them together.

I consider this suggestion original. I have not read Locke's Treatise on Human Understanding, nor Rousseau's Emile or Social Contract, but I've read others' summaries of the challenges presented by the argument between these two philosophers.

Our own heritage seems to mostly side with Locke, and all our intelligence these days is bent toward increasing the scope of natural science, i.e. our body of knowledge of the Lockean reality.

I claim this is original because I haven't seen it conclusively suggested yet, though for all I know, the old writing of Kant or Rousseau, or some contemporary philosopher in any of the hundreds of present-day universities, or some private philosopher doing work from the comfort of his own private library, may have already suggested it.

To flesh this out in detail: one of the two realities comprising human experience may be regarded as one of moral freedom, pressure, and personal risk, and within this matrix all of the old sayings and ponderings of virtue suddenly manifest. This state is somewhat like a dream. It is a dream in that you cannot seriously expect to study it with conventional scientific methods, or, if you can, you cannot break the dream down into its nano- or microscale atomic parts. You cannot even break it into human-sensible parts, at least not in the traditional meaning of sense-perception. You can, however, make some judgements and do some scientific-like work with it using reason, as has been done for centuries. This is the Roussiauian world.

And yet, we continue to interact directly with mother nature. We attempt to subdue her and understand her. I am referring to what we do with our machines, automations, and our physics. Our medicine extends life and fights mother nature's attempt to kill us abruptly. This is not completely divorced from what it means to be human, and so our science is not wholly for not. This is the Lockean part of the human experience.

It is the Rousseauian part that is at least essential, if not the most essential. In otherwords, you could create a dreamlike simulation for a person and still provide almost all of the essential elements needed for the human condition, or human experience. While we sleep, we often do.

Moving forward from this, some implications come to the surface:

  • Past and ongoing attempts to unify these two worlds can stop. We can replace them with efforts to more clearly articulate what it means for a person to be in both worlds at once, which is what I am very interested in doing as I continue my study of philosophy, including diving deeper into Locke, Rousseau, and their comrades.

  • Decartes's interpretation on how we must be distrustful of the dream state is not nearly as panic-inducing as one might think, and it almost appears as if he is unaware of, or trying to forsake, part of the Rousseauian element in the human condition. The same could be said about our dissapointment for any subject of Morpheus from the Matrix who would be content to take Morpheus' blue pill.

  • Nietzsche's analysis or morality is not really refuted at all, as he meant quite a lot when he said God was dead, but it does appear as though he assumed that the human experience was not really split into two concurrent realities, as I am suggesting here. He may have based a lot of his nihilism on the assumption that the Lockean world was all we had left, though his analysis of psychology after this seems to have led him straight back to the doorstep, if not far enough to re-enter, the Rousseauian reality again.

  • All of the old myths and religions suddenly have renewed value, since their content may be regarded as belonging entirely to the Rousseauian world and thus no longer subject to the demands of empirical science. God is back, it would seem. The very word "myth", in most minds, assumes that only one reality is experienced by a human at a single time, and in today's world that reality, as mentioned, is the Lockean one, and thereby one can quickly swat away the more extraordinary stories as being untrue and "mythical", without realizing that perhaps these stories need to be evaluated in the Rousseauian world.

  • Finally, and especially in the light of the just-mentioned point, any of the men who are headstrong and very eager to eradicate any mention of the Rousseauian world, including eradicating religion entirely - are suspect. It would almost be more precise to say "avoid" instead of "eradicate", for I would not be surprised if fear, or darker things, supply the motives that drive this part of such a man (I say "this part" since most men are not completely consistent - many men have conflicting motives and obey different ones at different times). They are attempting to kill what is essential in order to be human, and this is very strange. Something seems to be hidden from us when discussing things with these men. Men like these are easy to conjure up in one's short term memory. They hold considerable power today.

I could go on at great length with the implications but I need to stop at some point, and will stop here. If I am right, then this would hold wide-ranging implications for economics, psychology, and political science.

Sunday, June 23, 2013

On Admitting Unhappiness

A nasty bit of silliness, masquerading as insight, is the idea that happiness is a right, or that it is a choice.

This idea is politically correct. If you are a writing material for a Superbowl ad, dialogue for a television show, or a speech for a political campaign, then you can invoke this without much fear of public backlash.

Not only is it politically correct for those who produce mass media, but this idea is popular with the people. It has grass roots support from practically every modern American citizen. An electrician, a hair stylist, a boutique clothing store owner, a gourmet restaurant chef, and a public park's groundskeeper can all be counted upon to have a version of this idea in their mental toolbox of wisdom. They will use this device, though sometimes indirectly, to make decisions on what to buy, who to retain for friendship, and what type of job to seek.

If the leaders of politics, industry, and entertainment believe this, and if the everyday poor and middle class citizens believe this, is there any guard against it?

The belief that happiness is something that can be summoned relatively quickly, assuming you have sufficient willpower, is a natural consequence of denying any objective morality, of denying that we have to make moral choices that have long-lasting consequences, and finally, of denying any objective value in a human being.

The primary sadness of this idea is that it is false. It is incompatible with human nature. If someone can manage to suppress their human nature for a stretch of time while they put this platitude into place, all they accomplish is setting the stage for a raucous confrontation with reality later in life. For some of us, the stress that comes from harboring untruths might begin to spread through the bloodstream within ten minutes of committing this intellectual sin during day to day living.

Yet, this sin has propagated itself throughout the American world for about fifty years.

It is not without its many variants and cousins. From the family of ideas of which it is descendant also comes the idea that the rat race does not exist. If one chooses, one is exempt from the rat race. Chasing status, awards, or even making the choice to have a career makes you a tool of the modern industrial machine.

If you are going to believe that you can elect happiness into your daily life on just a moment's notice, then you may as well believe that the way you have lazily not worked hard to gain ground in the competition with every single person around you, including your own spouse, is perfectly fine.

You're going to need help convincing yourself of this in the face of reality. Yes, the approved messages of our topmost voices agree with you, and yes the the beliefs of the people around you agree with you, but you are still going to need more help convincing yourself of this.

I do not hesitate to acknowledge that Sigmund Freud's description of the ego in this regard seems exactly accurate with my experience in life, both within myself and throughout my perception of others. There really are habitual rationalizations going on inside our individual minds.

All of this is ridiculous. Which of you slows your car to a stop in an intersection during a red light, sees an aging man standing on the divider in the middle of the street, holding a cardboard sign with writing in black marker that says "Out of work veteran Dad, please help. God bless," and thinks to yourself, "this fellow has every right to be as happy as I am." Or better yet, "there is no difference between that man and me. We are equally happy, provided we both woke up and chose to be."

For fun, imagine the trains of thought that our subject idea could give you license to take seriously. You could tell yourself that the reason you don't have to give this man a couple dollars is because he is already happy, and your money will not make him any happier.

Oh I see, you're going to tell me that a bare minimum level of basic wealth is required and, after attaining this minimum level of wealth, happiness is merely a choice. A sort of Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs is at work here. Even a poor American must be expected to have a job and a roof over his head before he can be given membership into the true American society of those who can be happy whenever they want if they just choose to be.

Here is my response. You are raising a young boy. When your son is in the sixth grade in public school, it is time to go to his parent-teacher conference. You are a white collar, moderately successful lawyer, having recently put a sizable down payment on a three-bedroom house in the suburbs. This coming weekend, you plan to host a dinner party with friends you have known since your undergraduate college days. This occupies your mind as you walk up the staircase leading to your son's school teacher's classroom. You see her. She is white, about five foot four, in her late thirties, very overweight judging by her huge hips, disproportionately flat-chested judging, again, by her huge hips. Her cheeks are thick and a second chin appears as she walks up to you to introduce herself. She shakes your hand.

This woman made herself a sack dinner and what's left of it sits in a yellow lunch cooler on her desk. As she greets you, her breath is overheating and unpleasant, and as it hits your nose, your eyes briefly dart off to the side. Her disposition is nice to the point of being strenuous.

Prior to coming to this meeting, you had dinner at the California Pizza Kitchen.

Are you going to think to yourself "this teacher is exactly no more impressive and no less impressive than me. I'm sure she is exactly as happy as I am. If for some reason she isn't, well that's just silly - she has every right to be if she'd just made the same choice that I made this morning!"

She meets the bare minimum level of wealth requirement, but no, she is not as happy as you. She isn't. Even if she had talked to the mirror for two hours that morning before coming into work, she would not have been able to create the happiness that you know of. Your level of work and accomplishment, and its accompanying happiness in life, is so far beyond her reach that to verbally discuss some of the things you do with your spare time and money would be inappropriate and rude of you.

It is unsettling to see so many of my fellow citizens verbally and to some extent, mentally, going on pretending that they are happy. Or worse, going on hoping that the happiness they dream of is even a destination that they are currently making progress towards.

When we pretend that we are happy about everything, we are flagrantly disprectful to those who have superior happiness. Their superior happiness comes by virtue of their being more valuable than us.

We create delusion, and we spread this thick, black smoke of delusion through every street, house, and bedroom in our country, so that it smothers every heart that would otherwise like to go on beating like a human heart should. An human heart should yearn, long, lie awake restlessly, and have to fight off crippling melancholy instead of being sedated with nonsense. There is a potential link between our hearts and our minds, and taking the above idea seriously numbs this connection. It freezes it. It can severe it for years or a lifetime. Instead of this link between our conscious minds and our desires, which could lead to self-possession, what we get is the ego. We give our ego a tremendous amount of work to slave away on.

Every day we wake up and we are unhappy. Some of our unhappiness we may be responsible for, and some of it we may not be, but that is a separate matter - something to be considered at a later step.

Cornered, there is then talk of coming to terms with all this, of making peace with it, or learning to be content with it. This is more of the same request for reprieve. We shouldn't come to terms with it because there is no coming to terms with being unhappy. We shouldn't make peace with it because there is no peace to be had with unhappiness. We shouldn't be content because there is no contentment here. What we should do is admit it. And then mourn if we have to. Perhaps laugh a little through the tears once in awhile, but not too much, because that risks falling back into the trap that started all of this. Even if there is nothing we can do about it, we can at least spare our neighbor, who may still have a shot at happiness, the disrespect. Just because we can't have something doesn't mean we must deny its existence to everyone else.

And then we can go out and chase the reduced ration of happiness that we can still afford.

We go back to our statement about the rat race. The rat race is real, and if you pretend you are happy, you may as well also pretend that you don't have to compete in the rat race, when, in reality, you do have to compete in it. If you don't want your ego to fester and dedicate every cell in your body towards its rationalizations, resulting in an ever-increasing dependence on vicarious escapism due to you being parched at the throat for any recent well-earned personal joy, which culminates in a spiraling descent into bitterness for the remainder of your short life, then you must compete in the rat race.

There is another platitude that goes something like "learn to live within your means" and this is seldom heard in political campaigns, mass media, or everyday talk of the people. One of the reasons this is seldom heard is because, unlike the family of ideas we have been discussing, it is from the same ancestors of the idea that I am advocating here, which is that we are regularly unhappy and there is nothing we can do about it.

Living within your means, if you do the math, entails facing up to the consequences of the choices you have made in your life, some of which may have been extremely expensive to your past and yet yielded no benefit whatsoever to your present. Also, some of your present choices, though they may possibly bear fruit in the future, presently make you unhappy. They make you grouchy and irritated. They exhaust you.

Thanks in part to our wonderful technological advances, there is a voluminous body of writing these days, and to me, so much of it implicitly strives to give the reader an excuse to go on not taking responsibility for his or her own lack of happiness in life. A great first step to persuading the reader that they don't have to fight for their happiness is to quietly offer the suggestion that happiness is a right, or a choice. It so happens that the mere word choice - merely the word itself - is so overloaded and corrupted these past few decades, that many a listener is powerless to think critically about it.

If the aforementioned writing is not trying to do this, then there is a good chance that it instead tries to discredit third parties to the conversation who are legitimately taking action and having a morsel of success in their own pursuit of happiness in the rat race. It thus tries to arm the reader's ego with tools that it can use to tear down the valid happiness that the reader may see in other people's lives.

To those who would read this article of mine and conjecture that I am a member of this second group of popular writing, a mean person, a hater, or not a positive person, I ask how they would distinguish between this article and a shamelessly critical anonymous internet comment. The answer is that those commentators are hating on someone's work which may or may not be valuable, whereas I am hating on a treacherous principle that is used to excuse a person from attempting to produce value in the first place.

This growing body of writing accidentally ends up being a part of a sort of motherly hand, caressing the reader's cheek, leading the reader's lips to the iron nipple on its metallic breasts, where it can nurse the reader back into a slumber. The reader can gently doze off into pleasant dreams, awake the next day, and continue a life of inaction, a life of delusion without any accountability to himself: a childish life.

This symptom in today's writing is one of the reasons, though not the only one, that I am distrustful of most writing these days. For my own sanity, I try not to read or consume anything produced after the year 1960, including stuff produced today on Twitter or in the newspaper.

An exception to this rule includes material for my job, where I may be trying to solve a technical problem immediately, and the internet is indispensable in this case. Another exception is non-fiction history that I may be reading, though I have to read it critically for the reasons pervasive in this article. A final exception is material written by writers who admit that they are pursuing, and not merely claiming a right to, happiness, and who are not feigning exemption from the rat race. But such writers are rare, since writing such thoughts leads to being politically incorrect and unpopular.

I would suggest to you that you admit that you are unhappy, and identify whatever it is in your life that you are unhappy about. If you aren't sure where to start, a typical recommendation is just a threefold checklist that consists of, in no particular order, your romantic and sexual life, your career and wealth, and your physical health. This is not comprehensive, but it's a start. If one of these facets of your life isn't so impressive to you, then you can redirect your efforts to it.

These admissions should make it into your fundamental assumptions about life. They should strengthen the dialogue between your mind's educated consciousness and your heart's primitive desires. Also, they should make the people around you dislike you less.

This doesn't mean turning your life into a public spectacle, a caricature of depression, that makes everyone uncomfortable as they nervously laugh or blankly stare at your theatrics. As with everyone, even the happy, your behavior must remain calibrated and filtered. You have to keep your chin up while keeping much of your failure to yourself. Such is the frustrated life of being an unhappy person.

Admit that you are unhappy, lest we all plunge deeper into our current fall out of enlightenment and into savage madness.

Sunday, June 17, 2012

The Hand of the Mechanical Mother

Forward from June 2013: There are many things I regret about this article but its main point is something I still reuse a lot today. I've left it intact in its original form. If I could write it from scratch, it would probably be a better and more helpful article.

When you get into your $30,000 car, drive to The Cheesecake Factory, sit down to eat, have a pleasant conversation with the attractive waitress, then drive to the movie theater, get a bag of popcorn and watch Christopher Nolan's latest Batman movie, feel emotionally stimulated, come home five hours later feeling somewhat satisfied, write a post on your Facebook wall that contains some emotive exclaimation about what you thought of the movie, and doze in front of the television... Then you have effectively crawled under the comfort-building paw of the modern mechanical mother. And tonight millions of others like you enjoyed the fruits of the mechanical mother.

The mechanical mother is what gently keeps us from having any experiences of our own, experiences where we have to make decisions for ourselves. Oh sure, we make some small decisions when we're under the mother, like what to order off the menu, what movie to see, or what television channel to watch. But when we make these decisions, the worst that can happen to us is boredom or a lack of pleasurable stimulation. Little is at stake.

I call this the mechanical mother because it is both globalization and technology that has allowed a handful of decision makers on the planet (not merely in your country) to influence how so many of us spend our daily lives.

Whoever is in charge of The Cheesecake Factory, that guy and his team have shaped the menus, interior design, and attitudes of the waitresses so that when you went in there, you were being told what to do by him. And it was a high quality experience that he, or someone on his team, worked tirelessly to identify throughout his life in the food industry.

And the technology to shuttle so many ingredients onto that menu is directed by another guy, the factory farming guy. We've counted two teams so far.

Your car, the one you drove in, was designed by a legacy of hundreds of engineers, but again just a team of people holds the reigns on that car company. They did their best to get you to buy their car, and they succeeded. They got you. You got your car. Good for both you, so far.

Similarly for Nolan and his team, and the movie studio, and the television station staff, and the team of engineers at Facebook.

It would be different if we only used these tools at our disposal once in awhile, but are addicted. We spend every weeknight and weekend overdosing on whatever the mechanical mother has placed in our feeding trough.

This is a consumerism rant and not original. I have written about this before in much angrier tones before.

In this latest iteration of my rant, I have more respect for what the mechanical mother provides. Without her, so many of us would, in some sense, be more bored and underexperienced. The mechanical mother is such a smoothly running machine that even the poor people among us can afford to go out and have a good time.

Have you seen Christopher Nolan's movies? They are really good. Not all of us can afford to buy a private jet, fly it to our private island, and then go SCUBA diving in the nearby coral reef. So thank god that Nolan can give us something surprising. Have you tasted the food at The Cheesecake Factory? I haven't in a long time but its probably amazing.

But setting aside the issues of ability and relative poverty, there is something sinister and deprived about the mechanical mother. Let's begin our attack on it and see where we get.

The mechanical mother is providing imitation goods, and their quality is unknown. It is tweaked and fabricated. Christopher Nolan, honestly, doesn't know you and would probably have nothing but contempt for you if he spent 5 hours with you. The waitress at the restaurant really wants nothing to do with you; she would probably rather be doing something else with her girlfriends or boyfriend, but she has been told and trained to put on a smile, stay cheerful, and give you a pleasant experience. The people at the movie theater probably won't even try as hard as she did.

The handful (and I really do mean handful) of men and teams who run these industries do not sincerely care about you at all. They extract your money and, unlike you, can afford private jets, private islands, and SCUBA equipment. It is very possible that they don't need the mechanical mother at all - they may have their own sources of personal enjoyment with their freetime.

Thus, the mechanical mother is being run by people who are strong, independent, smart, and hard-working and they are taking full advantage of you in order to live their lives to their fullest. As they have no idea who you are, it is impossible for them to be sincerely invested in your well-being and growth. Every weekend and evening, when you come to nurse on the mechanical mother's mammary glands, you have no idea what is going to come out of there.

Not only that, if you've been dependant on the mechanical mother since you were young (say, ten) then you are so mentally immature that it is unlikely that you have any power to decide whether you are being fed something healthy or unhealthy. You lack a compass of quality. You don't know what healthy is. You have no taste.

I do not think that the people in control of these industries seek to ruin us; remember, we aren't even enemies to them. We are technically their customers. What really happens is that you get an organic machine where they are taking a small risk on what they think the poor wants to eat, the poor either buying or not buying what was given, and then the administrators and their peers adjust the product. It's a rapid feedback circle. No one is really in charge. (Think about that: No one is in charge). No one holds responsibility for what is going on here. That's why I like to say that you don't know what kind of milk the mechanical mother is producing. It just so happens that I think the vast majority of it is bad, but that's not my current point. It may be bad or it may be good, but no one is in charge of it.

I like that I picked Nolan because I think he is at least a "real" artist who sincerely cares about his vision and who makes decisions not based on peers or customers, but by examining what is inside of him. That is, he has (somehow) developed taste so that he can predict, all by himself, what will feel good to others, simply because it feels good to him. But at the end of the day he's just making movies and even his taste is fallable.

Another problem with the mother is that it prevents us from making decisions on our own and it kind of keeps us sedated. That old quote about religion being the opium of the people, well the religion isn't Christianity anymore, something else has taken its place and it resembles the entertainment and refined food industry, but its still is very much an opium for us.

There was an article I read awhile ago about how we used to work tirelessly, and we'd force our kids to work tirelessly, and the mere act of surviving and stressing over bills (with the kids) used to be sufficient to give us our experience in life. That, plus a general tendency to work outside in nature more. We all got thrown into the division of labor model of work, which was way more boring, and which pushed us to expect even more reward out of our limited freetime, and this all set the stage for the consumption culture we're in now. Whereas we used to have identities based on our work, we now have identities based on our consumption. Striking.

When I go out and consume, I am more conscious of what is going on now. When I walk into any room, whether it be a store or hotel lobby, and I see that it is refined, polished, and professionally decorated; and when its not obvious to me who the sole owner of the room is, then my "mechanical mother" alarm goes off. I immediately identify the room as belonging to the mechanical mother and I know that I am in a place equally suited for 10 year olds.

I am not so enlightened as to tell the mechanical mother exactly how she's doing her job wrong, but what really angers me is how she doesn't trust me to do anything on my own. There comes a point where it feels like I'm being insulted, like she's not just trying to feed me, but she's trying to spit in my face. She grabs me by the shoulders with her thick, fat sweaty fingers, she begins to turn red in the face, she violently shakes me, and shouts "feel good, god damnit Michael! Smile, god damn you! Start feeling good! Please start feeling good! Please, please, please start feeling good! Are you having fun yet? How about now? Have fun please!"

And I want to quietly ask her why she is trying so hard to force me to feel good, and also can she please stop shouting at me.

Today's globalization, insofar as it is part of the mechanical mother, is more than bringing us closer together. It is the means by which the mother rounds up her children into an even closer-knit herd. So many enfeedbled kids are being rounded up and stuck together in a pacified herd unlike any that's ever existed.

Some other day I might talk about the religious message that the mechanical mother is feeding us (in the place of Christianity), or I'll talk more about the moral privileges of the handful of people who take part in controlling part of the mechanical mother. I should also talk about what it means to be American, and how I think that is a reasonable defense against the life-stealing nature of the mechanical mother. Finally, I should also talk about culture sometime again. It's been awhile since I talked about culture.

I think the mechanical mother used to be in the hands of private families (and probably sincerely cared about you back then), but has only started becoming powerful and anonymous with the rise of national identity, improved publication and circulation of writing, and finally mass entertainment.

I think the only hope we have is the same hope that we've always had, which is for leaders (like say, me, or god forbid both of us) to walk through the herd, pinch people awake, and do a better job of personally, instead of anonymously, loving people. A flesh and blood human being talking to you, giving you something to do, and rewarding you feels so much better and worth pleasing than an anonymous, mechanical mother.